Answering service vs. voicemail vs. hiring: the real numbers

Compare the workflow as well as the bill: towing call intake needs location and dispatcher confirmation. Our after-hours answering guide explains what happens when the on-call phone does not answer.

There are four ways to handle a phone that rings when you can't answer it. Each has a real price, and the prices are further apart than most owners expect. This post uses published prices and government wage data, rechecked on 16 November 2026, and shows the arithmetic so you can redo it.

Voicemail: $0, and what that costs

AT&T (opens in a new tab) lists basic voicemail on wireless and prepaid plans and includes visual voicemail on compatible plans. Check what your carrier includes, then use the missed call cost post to estimate the value of work that could have been accepted.

Hiring a receptionist

The US Bureau of Labor Statistics puts the median receptionist wage at $18.27 an hour, or $38,010 a year (May 2025 data). Employers also pay 6.2% for Social Security and 1.45% for Medicare, according to the IRS, which is 7.65% together.

  • $38,010 a year, plus 7.65% ($2,908), is about $40,918 a year, or $3,410 a month.
  • That is before benefits, insurance, equipment, training and paid time off.
  • Example staffing arithmetic: one 40-hour schedule covers only part of a 168-hour week. Continuous coverage takes 4.2 full-time schedules, about $14,322 a month at the same wage and employer tax assumptions, before leave, breaks, overlap or other costs. This is an illustration, not a staffing quote.

A receptionist also does what software can't: greeting people at the door, handling paperwork and payments, knowing your regulars. If you have a front desk, that is worth paying for.

A human answering service

  • Ruby (opens in a new tab)'s published plans: $250 a month for 50 minutes, $395 for 100, $720 for 200 and $1,725 for 500. That is between $3.45 and $5.00 a minute.
  • Smith.ai (opens in a new tab)'s live receptionist plans: $300 a month for 30 calls, $810 for 90 and $2,100 for 300, with overage of $8.50 to $11.50 a call. That is between $7.00 and $10.00 per included call.

Compare equal work before comparing cost

Compare equal work before comparing cost
  1. Recognize the request

    Define the hours and decisions your front desk must cover.

  2. Record useful context

    Use the same call workload for each option.

  3. Choose the approved route

    Include the costs and limits listed in the original comparison.

  4. Confirm the next step

    Choose based on an acceptable handoff as well as the bill.

You are paying for a live person on your calls, 24/7. That is a real advantage, priced like one.

Automated answering

  • Rosie (opens in a new tab): $49 a month for 250 minutes, $149 for 1,000, $299 for 2,000, with a 7-day free trial.
  • Goodcall (opens in a new tab): $79, $129 or $299 a month, with 100, 500 or 2,000 unique customers respectively. Additional unique customers are $0.79, $0.26 or $0.15 on those tiers; minutes are not metered.
  • Smith.ai (opens in a new tab)'s automated plans: free for 25 calls a month, Pro from $150 for 75 calls, Enterprise from $500.
  • Wenly. Solo $29/month, Starter $99/month, Managed $249/month, and Custom from $449/month by quote..

Wenly Solo starts below Rosie and Goodcall's paid entry plans. Compare included minutes and customer limits on the comparison pages, not just the monthly price. Human-reviewed leads are included in Wenly Managed and Founding, not Solo or Starter. Provider, wage and tax sources were reopened on 16 November 2026. Quotes, taxes and account-specific charges can still differ; confirm the working plan before buying.

All of it in one table

Provider, wage and tax sources checked 16 November 2026
OptionPublished monthly costHours coveredWho answers
VoicemailIncluded on eligible carrier plansAvailable when your line forwards to voicemailA recording
One receptionistAbout $3,410 before benefitsAbout 40 of 168A person
Human answering serviceRuby (opens in a new tab) $250 to $1,725. Smith.ai live (opens in a new tab) $300 to $2,10024/7A person
Automated, low costRosie (opens in a new tab) $49 to $299. Goodcall (opens in a new tab) $79 to $299. Smith.ai (opens in a new tab) from $024/7Software
WenlySolo $29/month, Starter $99/month, Managed $249/month, and Custom from $449/month by quote.24/7Software; human-reviewed leads on Managed and Founding

Last checked . Follow the linked sources for current details.

Which one fits

  • Few calls, none urgent: voicemail is fine.
  • A front desk and walk-ins: keep the receptionist, and consider automated cover for the hours they're off.
  • A live voice matters more than price: a human answering service.
  • Every call answered at a price a small business can carry, and you don't need a person on the line: an automated service. Compare the allowance and how leads reach your team. Wenly includes human lead review on Managed and Founding.

If you want to see the arithmetic for your own business, the calculator is one click away. And if you'd like to hear it, call the demo.

Sources

Continue with answering service definition, voicemail comparison, after-hours answering scope.

Questions owners ask

Should a shop keep voicemail for some calls?

A checked mailbox can work for routine calls that can wait. For urgent requests, configure who can take a transfer and who receives the details if that person is unavailable.

Why are minutes and calls priced differently?

Minutes measure how long the caller spends on the line. A per-call allowance counts each billed call. Use both the call count and the total duration from your own phone log.

Can I use Wenly with someone at the desk?

Yes. Use conditional forwarding if your phone service supports it. Let the desk line ring first, then forward unanswered calls under the rules you agreed with the person at the desk.

Hear it answer. Then start free.

Seven-day trial, activated by our team once your line is ready (100 minutes, no card). Then pay monthly by card through our secure checkout. Cancel anytime.

Hear Wenly answer as your business

Your business, your greeting. Answered automatically.